Game 52, Mariners at Rangers
Logan Gilbert vs. Dane Dunning, 5:05pm
After a hard-fought series win in Baltimore, the M’s face another of the AL’s weaker teams. The Rangers have been quite bad in recent years, but their slow start is a bit more of a concern this season. I don’t think anyone had them challenging their in-state rivals in Houston, but you don’t add Corey Seager and Marcus Semien and expect to be an also-ran. Yes, yes, I know: they’re ahead of Seattle right now. But if the M’s start is seen by M’s fans as a massive disappointment and a brewing crisis, I think Rangers fans are one losing skid away from the same sorts of feelings. The M’s had higher expectations, but only just.
The problem is very similar to the one I talked about when the M’s hit Baltimore: Texas has failed to develop pitching. Unlike Baltimore, they haven’t had the problem of bringing in free agents or trade for vets who suddenly get worse. In fact, Texas had developed something of a reputation as a good place to go after getting quite a lot out of Lance Lynn and Mike Minor. But they haven’t had any success at all with pitchers they’ve drafted and developed. In recent years, they’ve been extremely active on the trade market, seemingly attempting to outsource the process of pitcher development to other, more successful, organizations. Thus, their rotation currently includes Glenn Otto (developed by the Yankees, acquired in trade), Taylor Hearn (developed by the Nats and Pirates, acquired in trade), Martin Perez (developed by the Rangers, but then laundered through the Twins and Red Sox orgs, acquired as free agent), Jon Gray (developed by the Rockies, acquired as free agent) and Dane Dunning (developed by the White Sox, acquired in trade – for Lance Lynn).
The Rangers have seen prospect after prospect stall out at or near the majors. They’ve traded a few, like Hans Crouse, but they’re still high on Cole Winn, who’s scuffling a bit in AAA, and Jack Leiter, perhaps the most anticipated pitching prospect in the game, who’s at AA and giving up more runs than he should. I’m not really sure what’s happened, as for years, the Rangers seemed to get a lot out of their prospects and pick-ups from other orgs (Nelson Cruz being the best example). But things have changed since Scott Servais was their minor league coordinator, and not many have been good. The Rangers once enviable pipeline of international free agents has dried up, and they’re struggling to develop league-average players to plug in around their big free agent acquisitions.
But there are encouraging signs that they’ve sort of bottomed out, and that their player development may be getting a bit better. Dane Dunning is an interesting case. He’d flown through the minors for the White Sox, pairing high ground ball rates with strikeouts, an optimal combination. What was powering those outcomes? A turbo sinker like Blake Treinen? Err, no. Dunning throws 88-89, and if I’d comp him to anyone, it would be as a right-handed Marco Gonzales. That sounds like a less-than-exciting prospect pedigree, but Dunning gets a lot out of mediocre raw stuff. Michael Ajeto tries to explain it over at Baseball Prospectus, and mentions one of the keys to Dunning’s success: batters don’t swing at his sinker when he throws it in the strike zone. He’s got the highest called-strike rate on his fastball of anyone in the game. That’s for any type of fastball, too, not just sinkers.
As a sinker/slider/change guy, he could have pretty significant platoon splits, and despite his neat trick of not getting swings on in-zone 88mph fastballs, he does. Lefties have traditionally done considerably better against them. Against them, he throws roughly equal numbers of sinkers and change-ups, and against righties, it’s a blizzard of sliders and cutters. What allows him to be playable and even effective against lefties at times is *how* he allows balls in play. Lefties have put more than twice as many change-ups in play as sinkers. He’s almost trying to let southpaws make contact with change-ups, where he, and the rest of the league, allow weaker contact. That’s a big reason why his average exit velo and thus his expected ERA is low. The best option is always to strike everyone out. If you can’t do that, the next best option is to have batters put balls and non-fastballs in play. This isn’t his plan against righties, though. Righties actually DO hit his sinker, and hardly ever swing and miss at it – but they struggle mightily to make contact with his slider. He gets far, far more ground balls against righties because of this; his sinking/running sinker is a grounder machine to righties. Thus, Dunning has two different approaches depending on the hitters’ handedness.
All of this hasn’t made him great yet, though, and in his relatively brief career, he’s posted better FIPs than ERAs. He’s given up a flurry of base hits, and his BABIP is super high despite the overall downward trend in BABIP and with a deadened ball. Bringing in the likes of Seager/Semien should help Dunning more than most, but to date, it hasn’t. That’s not the fault of the IFs, though – his BABIP on grounders is super low. Rather, it’s that he’s prone to giving up line drives. The M’s lefty-heavy line-up needs to barrel up those change-ups, something they’ve been pretty good at doing this year.
1: Winker, LF
2: France, 1B
3: Rodriguez, CF
4: Crawford, SS
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Frazier, DH
7: Toro, 2B
8: Trammell, RF
9: Raleigh, C
SP: Gilbert
With Kyle Lewis on the concussion IL, we’ll go back to seeing the DH slot rotate through a few different players depending on the handedness of the opposing starter. With Dunning on the mound, the M’s get to use it on an extra lefty tonight.
The R’s have been doing quite well in Reno, and won last night’s game 7-0. Justus Sheffield shut out the Aces for 6 to get his first AAA win of 2022. Jarred Kelenic led off the game with a dinger, but is still struggling somewhat – he’s got 8 Ks and 0 BBs in his last three games, going 3-16, but two of those three hits are homers.
Arkansas destroyed Springfield 16-5 – all 5 of the Cardinals runs came on solo shots. Kaden Polcovich led the attack for the Travelers with a home run and 4 hits in all.
Modesto beat Fresno 2-1 as Edwin Arroyo had two hits and Jimmy Kingsbury went 5 solid IP for the Nuts.
Everett was rained out, but they’ve got the rehabbing Ken Giles as the opener tonight.
Game 49, Mariners at Orioles
George Kirby vs. Bryan Baker, 4:05pm
After perhaps their best series of the year, the M’s head back out east to face the Orioles. Their last road trip put a serious dent in their playoff odds, so the M’s simply have to do better this time. Lucky for them, their quality of opposition drops noticeably. Instead of the Blue Jays and Rays, they get the Orioles and Rangers before resuming the difficult task of facing the Astros again.
Time has not been kind to the Orioles rebuild. Since the start of 2017, the Os are a combined *202* games below .500. They bottomed out in 2018 at 47-115, but then lost 108 games the very next year. After drafting well and building a well-regarded farm system, they came back strong in 2021…no, I’m sorry, they lost 110 games *again.* I understand that fans tolerate this sort of thing now, and that spending money to finish .500 is bad or inefficient or what have you, but, uh, this doesn’t look good, and it’s looked bleak for a while.
On the plus side, #1 prospect Adley Rutschman is now up and Grayson Rodriguez is in AAA. The line-up isn’t good, to be clear, but it looks like a bad MLB team and not a AA line-up anymore. Perhaps most crucially, and that’s kind of damning right there, the aggressive re-making of the left field dimensions at Camden Yards have allowed their pitching staff to more or less hold their own. Since 2017 began, the O’s have allowed 134 more home runs than any other team (Seattle is 3rd, 143 behind at 1,030). They pair that with the lowest K rate of any team in that span, AND a below-average walk rate.
Sure, the short porch in left was a factor, but the plain truth is that the Orioles pitching staffs have been bad because no one’s really tried to make them good. They’ve taken cast-offs from other orgs and watched them get worse (Andrew Cashner, Alex Cobb, Ubaldo Jimenez, Wade Miley), and they’ve brought up prospects and saw them flail or stagnate (Kevin Gausman, Dylan Bundy). The prospect failures aside, the team hasn’t prioritized getting good pitchers during this rebuild, and it shows. They haven’t really tried much this year, but the deader ball and the shockingly deep LF have combined to make the group sort of playable despite a bottom-third K-BB%.
The offense, though, hasn’t been helped a whole lot. They have a 90 wRC+ at home, killed by their lack of power. They’re not great anywhere, but their sudden turn to playing in a pitcher’s park has consequences. That means this is a good day for George Kirby to attack the hitters, something that’s essentially been his MO since he was drafted. It’s not always a great plan, and he’s scuffled slightly in his last two starts – he’s given up 16 hits and three HRs in his last 10 IP. Here, though…why not?
Opposing him is the Orioles’ journeyman spot-starter, Bryan Baker. Baker was drafted by the Rockies, and made one appearance out of the Jays bullpen last September before being waived. A reliever, his presence as the starter portends a bullpen game – see above for the O’s hesitance to spend money on the rotation, OR to have to spend money later by bringing up Rodriguez too soon. Baker throws a four-seamer and a cutter, and as such, has some platoon split issues. He’s trying to remedy them by learning a change, but he hasn’t trusted it too much thus far – still, his MLB career is all of 20 IP long, so it’s not like he can’t reinvent himself. At 94-95, his fastball’s decent, and he’s had great results with it in his brief career. The cutter, though, just hasn’t been big-league quality.
I know Orioles fans have been through a lot. I know many are excited to cheer on Rutschman and Rodriguez (eventually). But I wonder what they think of watching yet another team stumble to the AL East cellar? I bet many, many people wonder why we’re all still watching the M’s try and fail to make the playoffs, and there’s the kernel of a disappointingly good question in there. But there’s one thing about watching a team try, maybe not as hard as we’d all like, with plenty of missteps here and there, but *try* – and whatever it is the Orioles are doing. I know, I said something very similar about the White Sox a few years ago, and their aggressive rebuild finally starting paying off. And even they weren’t *this* bad *this* often. I have seen M’s teams put up 100 loss seasons, and no, there’s no meaningful difference between 105 losses, say, and 110. But losing 100 in the last three full seasons and starting out in last place again? I don’t know that I could keep caring, even as I’m sure the fans are treated to every encouraging performance on the farm, and reminded about the importance of the draft. At some point, though, the will runs out.
1: Winker, DH
2: France, 1B
3: Rodriguez, CF
4: Crawford, SS
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Frazier, 2B
7: Moore, LF
8: Trammell, RF
9: Raleigh, C
SP: Kirby
With a Covid outbreak sidelining the Rainiers manager and batting coach, the M’s have turned to Dan Wilson to take the helm of the Rainiers as they head to Reno this week. Good luck, Dan!
Game 47, Astros at Mariners
Logan Gilbert vs. Jose Urquidy, 7:10pm
When was the last time the Mariners were favored in a match-up with the Astros? Not sure, but it can’t have been too recently. But that’s exactly what we have tonight, as the M’s surprising ace, Logan Gilbert, faces off against the underbelly of the Astros rotation.
Let’s be clear: Jose Urquidy isn’t a bad pitcher. For years, he’s beaten his FIP through low BABIPs driven by fly balls and infield pop-ups. To his credit, he’s been extremely stingy with walks as well. It’s just that this season, the whole BABIP-suppression thing isn’t working, and he’s allowed 52 hits in just over 40 IP. That sort of thing just isn’t *done* anymore; he’d have been a star in the 1980s, but is verging on anachronism now.
He seems odd because he doesn’t strike a ton of batters out, and he’s a rare fastball/change-up guy – kind of a right-handed crafty lefty. The change has been easily his best pitch, and it’s often why he’s able to get poor contact and pop-ups. It’s also driven his sharply reversed platoon splits. In his career, lefties have a .253 wOBA against him, while righties are up at .332. That speaks both to the high quality of his change, but also the relative weakness of his breaking stuff. Righties should not be able to hit that well against him.
So, what’s happening this year? Well, his dominance of lefties is over with, at least for now. They’re destroying the ball, and his change-up is at the heart of it. I’m never really sure why pitchers with a great weapon want to change it, but Urquidy came into 2022 with a new change, or rather, he extended some changes he’d been making through 2021. Over the course of that season, he started throwing his change faster – from 84 and change to a bit over 86 mph this season. That didn’t change the horizontal run on the pitch, but it has reduced its vertical drop (as you’d kind of expect). By getting more active spin on his fastball, his heater’s vertical movement moved up through 2021 even as it lost velocity. But still, the changes were larger on the change, and the upshot is that there’s less of a gap in either speed or vertical break than there used to be. Lefties seem to have noticed. Hell, everyone has. He throws the pitch to righties too, and even they are hitting him better this year.
Logan Gilbert and Urquidy are very, very different pitchers, but, uh, Gilbert’s career platoon splits show a .254 wOBA for lefties and a .324 for righties. The driver in this case is much more the fastball than the change, but I think it’s pretty obvious at this point that Gilbert’s change is his second best pitch. An effective pitcher overall without a very good breaking ball…that descriptor works for both pitchers tonight. Michael Ajeto wrote up the evolving Gilbert over at Baseball Prospectus, talking about him using more of his secondaries in recent starts, and the change in particular. That bears watching in tonight’s contest.
Like Urquidy, Gilbert has a re-made change in 2022. Last year’s version was slow – down at 80 mph and with plenty of vertical drop. This year, Gilbert’s change averages 86+ mph – over 6 mph added to the pitch in one year. As with Urquidy, this has had some impact on its vertical movement, and sure, it’s shrunk the gap with his fastball. But Gilbert’s pitch has better movement; it really dives despite the added oomph. It was a very unsuccessful pitch last year, with MLB giving it a run value of +6, an absolutely terrible figure for a pitch thrown infrequently. This year, it’s down at -2; it’s already saved 2 runs despite the fact he’s still using it sparingly (below 10% of his pitches). Throw it more, Logan!
1: Winker, LF
2: France, 1B
3: Rodriguez, CF
4: Crawford, SS
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Frazier, 2B
7: Lewis, DH
8: Trammell, RF
9: Raleigh, C
SP: Gilbert
Game 46, Astros at Mariners: Caring
Chris Flexen vs. Justin Verlander, 6:40pm (This is the last of the early starts this season. Tomorrow’s game will begin at 7:10).
The M’s are in last place after a disastrous stretch of poor play. The game itself seems to stumble; the ball is dead on the whole, but subject to striking variance from game to game. This is both kind of annoying and also lends itself to conspiratorial thinking. I mean, if you *wanted* to enrich your new partners in the gaming industry, wouldn’t this be a good way to do it? Baseball’s broadcasts are splintered into several competing platforms, as MLB tries to profit off of the streaming wars that threaten its big cable revenue streams. And, yes, all of it – good and bad – pale in comparison to what we see on the news every night. I’m a parent, and needed some off days from whatever this is. Now, more than ever, it’s harder to have a great answer when someone asks why you like the Seattle Mariners.
Roger Angell famously said, “It is foolish and childish, on the face of it, to affiliate ourselves with anything so insignificant and patently contrived and commercially exploitative as a professional sports team, and the amused superiority and icy scorn that the non-fan directs at the sports nut (I know this look – I know it by heart) is understandable and almost unanswerable. Almost. What is left out of this calculation, it seems to me, is the business of caring – caring deeply and passionately, really caring – which is a capacity or an emotion that has almost gone out of our lives. And so it seems possible that we have come to a time when it no longer matters so much what the caring is about, how frail or foolish is the object of that concern, as long as the feeling itself can be saved. Naïveté – the infantile and ignoble joy that sends a grown man or woman to dancing in the middle of the night over the haphazardous flight of a distant ball – seems a small price to pay for such a gift.”
Today, David Roth wrote a great post at Defector on Angell and caring, and it struck a chord. We all care so much about this strange game, and we seem to get so little out of it – especially those of us following such a flawed entity as the Mariners. I keep wanting there to be a great origin story of my fandom, an answer to why we might care about the haphazardous flight of a distant ball. But there’s not.
I don’t remember anything before loving sports. I would wake up early every Sunday and stare at the Ed Hume gardening show because once it ended, the NFL pregame show would appear. I could’ve watched something else until then, or nothing at all, but I couldn’t move lest I miss a note of the opening theme. Football was always a TV spectacle, and kids are attuned to things that reek of spectacle, so maybe that was easier. But baseball did the same thing. I think I saw bits and pieces of the 1980 World Series, and that was just that. I liked what was going on without knowing what was going on, and I haven’t stopped yet. Little bits and pieces just get appended to your identity at that age, but that one stuck.*
Much of the next decade was having that care – the unearned, almost subconscious care – rewarded and bolstered by things like going to the Kingdome, the arrival of Mark Langston and Alvin Davis, and then, the miraculous and all-conquering coming of Ken Griffey Jr. It was not rewarded with a whole lot of winning, but by the sense that winning would arrive soon. I wasn’t in the area for the miracle comeback of 1995, but I was in grad school in 2000, the beginning of that short, glorious period of M’s success. A friend got tickets to game 3 of the ALDS in 2000, the first playoff game in what is now T-Mobile stadium, and we sat out in center field on a warm fall day. Memorably, the game ended on a walk-off drag bunt by Carlos Guillen, and the stadium went wild. It was cathartic, it was ecstatic, it was repayment for years and years of frustration and potential moves and awful owners. We stood and yelled, not moving, for a long time, and then, suddenly, Mike Cameron leapt on to the CF wall. To this day, I smile every time Cameron pops on a broadcast, or when he’s shown working with OFs in spring training. He was there, literally climbing the barrier between player and fan, when all of that caring seemed to be repaid, when all of us, players and fans, knew how deep that care went.
The Mariners are, again, bad. Or at least: they’re playing like a bad team. This week of all weeks it is easy to stop caring and get back to caring about the things we all need to care about. It is *harder* to care now, and it’s why I am consciously trying to keep doing it. As Roth writes, “When that light goes out, it stays out; what keeps it on, whatever keeps it on, seems very valuable.” I don’t want the light to go out, and I hope you don’t either. I can’t blame you if it does, and there are days when it seems like it’d be easier – more rewarding, maybe – to let it. But that’s too easy – we care about hard, imperfect things, and boy do the Mariners check both boxes.
1: Frazier, LF
2: France, 1B
3: Rodriguez, CF
4: Crawford, SS
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Lewis, DH
7: Trammell, RF
8: Raleigh, C
9: Haggerty, 2B
SP: Flexen
Connor Jones threw a 7 inning no-hitter for Arkansas yesterday as the Travs swept a double header. Levi Stoudt starts tonight for them against the Amarillo Sod Poodles.
Las Vegas is in Tacoma to take on the Rainiers. Vegas won last night 5-2; Pierce County native Nate Mondou went 0-4 for the Aviators.
Adam Macko starts for Everett tonight.
* One that didn’t was being “Steve.” There were so many Steves in the NFL that it seemed like a smart move to re-name myself to fit in with what I assumed would be my future colleagues.
Game 43, Athletics at Mariners
Marco Gonzales vs. Zach Logue, 6:40pm
After a disastrous series in Boston, the M’s again turn to their stopper. No, not the defending Cy Young, or one of their young phenoms, but Marco Gonzales. I’d worry that he wouldn’t have the same competitive fire facing a near anonymous starter in Zach Logue, not a name brand Ace like Max Scherzer, but I think Gonzales is literally made of competitive fire.
Look, this has been a rough month for the M’s. Nathan Bishop wrote a great blog post about the feeling they’ve inspired. It’s hard to remember when they’re on a losing jag like this, but they’re not a horrible team – they’re a perfectly fine team who’s *playing* poorly at the moment. But the flip side to that, and one Nathan hits on, is that so much of the hope that April engendered wasn’t real either. Apparently, JP Crawford isn’t an 8-9 WAR player, who can hit for average and power, while playing a brilliant SS. Apparently, Matt Brash is going to take some time, and apparently, Logan Gilbert – while great – is not nearly unhittable.
Still, I loved reading Ryan Divish’s reminder that the club that won 90 games last year were very close to this a year ago. The M’s were 21-26, in 4th place in the AL West. They were the worst hitting club around, with the lowest average and OBP. Their bullpen wasn’t yet the savior of the team, as the first group had to make way for Paul Sewald and others. So it’s possible for a team to look lost, to look punchless, and come out of it. The problem is that, outside of a brilliant bullpen, the M’s didn’t come out of it by playing like a 90 win team – they came out of it by…I mean, I watched it, and I still have no idea how it happened. The M’s will improve in the coming weeks. Their worst hitters won’t stay this bad, and they’ll bolster the line-up by getting guys off the IL. The bullpen will play better.
That said, this team is not competing for a title. This club that fancied itself among the AL’s up-and-comers simply isn’t. That sucks; this fanbase has waited a long, long time. But for a number of reasons, they’re just not as good as the top clubs in the league, and may not be as good as mid-tier teams. What’s tough to figure out is what to do from here. Think of a guy like Adam Frazier, who’s a free agent at the end of the year. Mitch Haniger, too, and I just can’t see the M’s making a run at keeping him. The M’s are going to need to be very active in free agency to stay on the outskirts of contention, and they’ll need continued growth from Julio and a massive bounce-back from Jarred Kelenic.
That sounds like a tall order from a club that’s been hesitant to do much in free agency, and whose record with their top prospects has been, uh, spotty. But it’s not impossible. That said, what may be impossible is to re-focus on something more than contention. It’s so easy to say, but it’s not so easy to do.
Today, the M’s face the rebuilding A’s, the one team below the M’s in the AL West. Today’s starter is Zach Logue, whom the A’s acquired from Toronto in the Matt Chapman deal. A low 3/4/side-arming lefty, Logue throws a 90mph four-seamer, a change-up, a slider/cutter, and a slurvy curve. Despite his low vertical movement, his fastball isn’t really a sinker – especially given the way he uses it.
Logue slings in his fastball at or above the top of the zone.
In the high minors, this approach gave him the ability to rack up strikeouts. 90mph isn’t going to allow that at the big league level, but it does have another effect: Logue has one of the league’s lowest GB%. He’s really like a left-handed Paul Sewald, er, with 3mph less oomph, and as a starter. Sewald ran a sub-30% GB rate last year, and Logue’s at 25% himself. In an earlier era of baseball, like 2019, this would be…a really bad plan. But in 2022, with a dead ball, playing in Oakland (and visiting Seattle), that’s a decent idea. A .264 BABIP is probably not all that unlucky, though his strand rate of 93.4% most definitely is.
1: Frazier, 2B
2: France, 1B
3: Crawford, SS
4: Rodriguez, CF
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Winker, LF
7: Moore, RF
8: Torrens, DH
9: Raleigh, C
SP: Gonzales
The end of Kyle Lewis’ rehab forced a choice from the M’s front office. And thus, Lewis is on his way to Seattle and might play tomorrow. For a guy who has needed days off after playing less than a full game in the OF, he seems likely to be a full-time DH. And that’s fine – the M’s are platooning Luis Torrens and Mike Ford in that position now. But it also means that the M’s professed desire to wait until Lewis was 100% healthy couldn’t survive this losing streak.
Game 42, Mariners at Red Sox: Desperation Time?
Logan Gilbert vs. Nathan Eovaldi, 10:35am
After another heartbreaking loss – another big early lead squandered – the M’s will need to make even more roster moves. Abraham Toro’s injury in yesterday’s game will necessitate an IL stint, and Steven Souza’s poor play necessitated a roster move as well. The ideal replacement for the latter would be Kyle Lewis, but the organization is talking about his health the way they did about Jay Buhner’s in 2001: general soreness and years of wear and tear making it all but impossible to say whether he’ll be able to play the field on a given day (a reminder that life is often cruel, and baseball is crueler). So, the M’s have made a short term move and a longer term one. For the former, they’ve brought Taylor Trammell back from extended spring training where he’d been rehabbing an injury he picked up in the season’s first week in Tacoma. For the latter, they’ve signed free agent OF Justin Upton, who’d been cut by the Angels at the end of spring.
With Souza’s DFA’d and Toro IL’d, there’s still an open active roster spot. Thus, old friend Sam Haggerty is back from Tacoma to fill in. Adrian Sampson, who’d just been signed on May 13th, has been DFA’d to make room on the 40-man. Let’s be clear: the M’s needed to make moves. What’s less clear is if these moves will help. The M’s decided to punt defense a bit with Souza, and it now seems like they’ll re-prioritize it with Trammell, whose MLB hitting performance is…not great. The back-up to the back-up infielder doesn’t matter so much, but the M’s depth is being sorely tested, and they’re getting kind of desperate. Dylan Moore may need to stick around the infield more going forward, and the M’s just have to hope that Trammell is ready to go despite not playing a minor league game, or that Upton can get back to game speed in the next few weeks.
Today, the M’s will be desperate to salvage a game in this series. They get perhaps their best starter on the mound, and facing an opposing starter who got demolished in his last outing. But that doesn’t make the M’s favorites. Nathan Eovaldi was off to a great start for Boston, and has a great walk rate and K rate, but 5 HRs in one disastrous inning against the Astros mar his seasonal stats. Sure, that game was essentially played in a wind tunnel, but the HRs counted just the same.
As a guy with a big fastball, does Eovaldi’s game plan run right into the M’s batting strengths? Eh, not really. While it’s 95-97mph, Eovaldi’s throwing his four-seamer only 40% of the time, far less than yesterday’s starter, Garrett Whitlock. Eovaldi’s arsenal is a deep one, and he mixes in a curveball, a slider, a splitter, and a rare cutter. The slider’s his primary breaker against righties, and it’s been weaker than normal in 2022 thus far, but his curve’s been solid against both lefties and righties. He uses the splitter not as a change-up, where he’d target lefties with it, but as an equal-opportunity weapon.
Gilbert’s given up at least 3 R in the last three starts, but he’s been the victim of poor defense and some bad luck. He’s remained a surprising strikeout threat throughout even this dip in form, and he’s yielded so few HRs on the year. That combination makes him a serious threat to win every game he starts.
1: Frazier, 2B
2: France, 1B
3: Crawford, SS
4: Rodriguez, CF
5: Winker, LF
6: Suarez, 3B
7: Ford, DH
8: Raleigh, C
9: Trammell, RF
SP: Gilbert
Tacoma’s game last night featured one of the most eye-popping performances in years. Starting pitcher Daniel Ponce de Leon started the game with *9 consecutive strikeouts.* That’s clearly a Tacoma record, and it’s believed to be the most in the long history of the PCL. de Leon finished with 5 scoreless innings, giving up only 1 hit and striking out 12 against 1 walk. That’s…astonishing. Nick Margevicius gave up 6 runs in 2 in relief, but the Rainiers had built up a big lead and won 10-6. Jarred Kelenic went 3-5 with a couple of doubles, and SS Mason McCoy had two HRs. Today, Justus Sheffield gets the start; he’s had a rough start to his PCL stint this year.
NW Arkansas took Arkansas apart, winning 11-4. Today, SP prospect Emerson Hancock gets the start for the Travelers.
Everett won 9-3 over Hillsboro, hitting three home runs in the process. Adam Macko had a so-so start, going only 4 IP, walking 5, but striking out 6. Bryce Miller starts for Everett today.
Stockton blanked Modesto, 4-0.
Game 41, Mariner at Red Sox: Let the Worrying Commence
Chris Flexen vs. Garrett Whitlock, 1:10pm
After another loss last night, the M’s are now two back of the Rangers in 4th in the West. Sure, it was good to see the Astros lose so the gap to the division leaders didn’t grow, but watching Martin Perez of all people throw a complete game shutout against them (in 2022??!) made it much tougher for M’s fans. The Rangers might hang around here for a while. The M’s, meanwhile, fell to 17-23 after 40. No, last year’s club wasn’t great in May, but they were 20-20 after 40 games. Three games down isn’t a ton, and there’s a lot of baseball left. But they need to show some signs of life, and signs that they can not just win the odd game against a Max Scherzer or Aaron Nola or whoever, but that they can grind out series wins against good teams. That’s what they did time and again last year, and it’s something they’ve struggled with in 2022.
What are the M’s good at, as a group? One of the more surprising things, at least for me, is this: they’re the league’s best team at hitting fastballs. By pitch type run values, no team’s done better on fastballs. Convert it to a rate, doesn’t matter: they’re really good at it. Part of this is just the kinds of hitters they have – Julio has struggled with spin, but does a good job against heat. Part of it is that they have a great approach: they’re good at knowing when to swing and when not to. But against the pitches thrown most often, they’ve done a great job.
The flip side of this is that the scouting report or opposition research kind of writes itself. Give them change-ups. Sliders. Curves. Doesn’t really matter; just avoid the fastball. Thus far, the M’s have seen comparatively *more* fastballs than other teams, though that may just be the result of facing the Twins and then Justin Verlander twice. Still, I worry that other teams knows what the M’s are good at it (and less good at), and can pitch accordingly. I worry that this may be behind their poor performance late in games – relievers with a good breaking ball can be effective.
Last year, the M’s bullpen was a major strength. They were good, but they played better than that, and when it mattered most, they somehow played even better. The true talent in this year’s pen is probably better, but…they’re not really playing well. We marveled at their clutch score last year, but this year, it’s just above zero (which is in itself cause for muted celebrations, given their overall performance and win probability added). They have 22 games in which they’ve significantly bettered the M’s chances of winning (measured by win probability added), but 21 in which they’ve significantly hurt it – last night’s game was such an occasion. That ratio of shutdown games to meltdown games is in the bottom three in the league; no one is close to Seattle except Washington and Cincinnati. In 2022, you do NOT want to be near those clubs in anything.
Garrett Whitlock is probably the best Rule 5 pick of recent years. He’d been a Yankee farmhand and pitched very well, but went down in late 2019 with an elbow problem and needed Tommy John. The Yankees, in one of their perpetual 40-man roster crunches, thought they could leave him unprotected after he missed 2020 with rehab. Boston picked him anyway, and he rewarded them with a brilliant season of in relief last year. He tossed over 73 IP in 2021 with an ERA under 2, firing a mid-90s sinker with a very good slider and change-up.
After starting in relief this season, the Red Sox moved him into their rotation, figuring that a good three pitches (plus a fourth, a rarely-used four seamer) would play for multiple PAs. The only question would be platoon splits. His platoon splits were pretty elevated last season, with his slider – his best pitch, probably – not as much of an option against lefties. Well, so far, it hasn’t mattered. His change was solid last year, but it’s been a dominant pitch this year. Cameron Grove’s pitching bot rates it a 70 by stuff+, and 65 (on the scouting scale) overall. In fact, he’s running reverse splits thus far. I don’t expect that to last, but it shows that Whitlock has the arsenal to stick in the rotation and to do it well. His K rate is up over last year, and it’s up even more as a starter. The saving grace here for the M’s is that he relies pretty heavily on fastballs. Get a sinker and drive it, M’s.
1: Frazier, RF
2: France, 1B
3: Crawford, SS
4: Rodriguez, CF
5: Winker, LF
6: Suarez, 3B
7: Toro, 2B
8: Ford, DH
9: Torrens, C
SP: Flexen
Don’t look now, but the Rainiers are actually hot. They won their second straight shutout yesterday, blanking Sacramento 2-0. Konner Wade won his 2nd game as the R’s yielded just 3 hits. Of course, they only got 3 hits themselves, but made ’em count.
Arkansas slipped past NW Arkansas 2-1, with Jake Haberer getting a win in relief and Levi Stoudt tossing his best game, with 5 2/3 scoreless and 7 Ks.
Everett got 2 in the 7th to get past Hillsboro 7-5. The deadly top 3 of the Frogs line-up (Marte/Packard/Alberto Rodriguez) went 0-13 with 7 Ks, but the bottom of the line-up picked ’em up. C Andy Thomas had 3 hits including his 3rd HR. Adam Macko starts today’s game for Everett.
Modesto demolished Stockton 11-3, as Edwin Arroyo hit his 8th bomb of the year. The 18 year old now has a .952 OPS on the year.
Game 40, Mariners at Red Sox – RIP, Roger Angell
Robbie Ray vs. Michael Wacha, 4:10pm
“My gratitude aalways goes back to baseball itself, which turned out to be so familiar and so startling, so spacious and exacting, so easy looking and so heartbreakingly difficult, that it filled up my notebooks in seasons in a rush; a pastime indeed.”
– Roger Angell’s Hall of Fame Induction speech
The greatest baseball writer of all time, Roger Angell, died at his home today in New York. He was 101. He watched essentially every great star of the game, from Babe Ruth, to a rookie Willie Mays, to Mike Trout and Juan Soto. We’ve lost a brilliant prose stylist, a keen observer, and someone who made you proud to be a baseball fan. But because he’d been watching and thinking about the game so long, he seemed to essentially embody baseball history itself, at least the part after it became a big, professional institution. It is sad to lose that first-person perspective on baseball history, but I am always thankful he turned those memories, those sights, into something timeless.
I’ve been thinking in recent years about just how *glad* I am that a writer like Patrick Dubuque chose to write about baseball. There are so many things to write about, so many things to care about or follow. The odds seem stacked against the alignment of a singular voice and this odd game, one that always frets it’s too old and past its prime. So when it happens, I don’t want to forget to feel thankful. Roger Angell is the clearest example of that, the writer who made it possible for thousands to come after him, to raise this silly game into something worthy of his words.
It’s weird; just given things like blogs, I’ve probably read more words from Dave Cameron and Jeff Sullivan than I have of Angell’s (though I’ve read a lot of them). At no point ever did I think, “Wow, that’s very Angell-ian.” But he didn’t inspire imitation; that would be difficult, and the potential for cringe would be sky-high. He inspired coming at the game honestly, and thoughtfully, and thus I think people like Sullivan or Dubuque or Rowley or DMZ really can be seen as heirs.
Yesterday’s game was a brutal one, a big early lead given back almost immediately, and then a bizarre gaffe by a manager just trying to execute a pitching change. Whatever the cause, the M’s seemed helpless to stop the Red Sox and Trevor Story, who hit three home runs. The Sox enter today just a half-game back of the M’s. An already-cluttered wild card race could get even more stuffed soon. It’s not a shock or anything; this Sox club is way too talented to be a bottom-feeder, even in the AL East.
With three wild cards, the M’s chances aren’t as dour as they’ve looked on this road trip, but the problem is the two-tiers of playoff hopefuls, with the Angels/Rays/Jays looking like a very different group of hopefuls than, say, the Guardians and M’s. I think you could add the White Sox to that former group as well. The M’s simply aren’t this bad, and should start winning more games sometime soon, perhaps after this brutal road trip. But the first 39 games happened; they don’t get to start fresh.
Robbie Ray’s K rate is down slightly this year, as he’s getting just a couple fewer swinging strikes each start. It’s not a lot, and he’s striking out more than a batter an inning, so it’s not necessarily a problem. It’s not like those missing whiffs and K’s are turning into HRs; just like the rest of the league, his HR/9 is down. The problem is that those missing Ks are turning into balls in play. As a result, some innings look fine, but if some hits string together, he’s suddenly given up a big inning. But why is he giving up more balls in play?
One reason is that after moving back to the AL, he’s not facing very many lefties anymore. Over his career, Ray has had the platoon advantage in 22% of his PAs-against. It was slightly higher with the Diamondbacks, then it dipped to 18% last season. This year, it’s just 14%, a clear low mark in his 9-year career. And while his K% against righties has been high, and almost as high as it’s been against lefties, it’s still lower – and this year, that gap has grown.
Michael Wacha came up as a phenom in 2013, pitching well in critical postseason games just a year after being drafted by St. Louis. As a change-up maven without a huge fastball, he flew through the system, and essentially cut the trail that Marco Gonzales would follow just a year later; Gonzales was drafted in the summer of 2013, and got some postseason experience in 2014. But after a brilliant first full season, injuries and ineffectiveness took over.
The Cardinals let him go, and his 2020 campaign with the Mets was a disaster. He found himself with Tampa a year ago, and I think a lot of fans expected that if anyone could fix him, it’d be the Rays. It didn’t happen. Too many HRs, occasional injuries – it just didn’t work, and after one year and an ERA over 5, he landed with Boston. He’s already had one IL stint, but so far, so good for Wacha.
He’s got strong reverse splits for his career thanks to that change, but he still strikes out more righties. It’s weird; even against righties, if he needs a chase or a strikeout, he goes to the change. It’s mostly effective, but if they hit it, it tends to go a long way. Lefties make awful contact on the pitch, and thus have poor overall numbers against Wacha (he throws the change more than his FB to lefties). Wacha’s worked on other pitches for righties – a cutter, a curve – but he remains mostly a FB/CH guy.
1: Frazier, DH
2: France, 1B
3: Crawford, SS
4: Rodriguez, CF
5: Winker, LF
6: Suarez, 3B
7: Toro, 2B
8: Moore, RF
9: Raleigh, C
SP: Ray
Today’s roster move is that Matt Festa’s back, replacing Wyatt Mills. Festa’s remade slider has him missing more bats than his prior stint in the bigs, but he’s been unable to avoid the home run.
The bigger roster move is upcoming. Kyle Lewis’ rehab stint officially ends on Monday. He’s played three games in a row for Tacoma, but they’ve all come as a DH. As Mike Curto notes, Lewis played 7 innings in the OF back on May 4th, and hasn’t played there since. It seems exceedingly unlikely the M’s could hope to use Lewis there in the majors. But with their offense sputtering, maybe they could actually use a part time DH? The M’s have said repeatedly that they wanted Lewis 100% before calling him up. A few weeks into his rehab, he’s not there yet. They could re-start the 20 day clock after Monday, and if they want something more than a DH, that’s what they’ll have to do. But the bottom of the line-up is rough, and the guys the M’s keep rotating through the DH spot could all play the field; this isn’t a Dan Vogelbach situation. This is one to keep an eye on. Please get healthy, Kyle.
Speaking of health, apparently C Tom Murphy had a setback with his shoulder, and thus won’t be coming off the IL when his stint ends. Damn.
Dipoto talked about Jarred Kelenic on 710am yesterday, saying that they just want him to have fun. I get what they’re saying, but they almost seemed wary of giving him specific things to work on, outside of potentially take/swing decisions.
The Rainiers are in Sacramento, and they destroyed the hosts 11-0 yesterday with old friend Tommy Milone getting the win after 5 scoreless. Jarred Kelenic hit his first AAA HR of the year. Konner Wade makes his third start for Tacoma tonight against Tristan Beck.
Arkansas blanked NW Arkansas 5-0, as Jake Scheiner hit his 6th HR. Levi Stoudt starts for the Travelers tonight.
Everett didn’t get the memo, and gave up a solo HR in the first, but then got things on track, and shut out Hillsboro the rest of the way to win 6-1. Spencer Packard hit his 7th for the Frogs. Prelander Berroa, the SP the M’s got from San Francisco a few weeks back, makes his second start in the org.
Modesto misinterpreted the memo, and got shut out by Stockton 5-0. Ports starter Luke Anderson was scoreless, obviously, for 5 2/3 IP with 8 Ks but 7 BBs. That’s filling up the box score.
Game 39, Mariners at Red Sox
George Kirby vs. Rich Hill, 4:10pm
Yesterday’s win was the second-straight crucial win in a game the M’s were just overwhelming underdogs. Both were started by Marco Gonzales, and in both, he was opposed by one of the best starters in baseball. I know we all know Marco’s a competitive guy, but he seems to take it *personally* when he’s given no chance, or has his stuff compared unfavorably against, you know, Max Scherzer and Kevin Gausman. It is Marco’s superpower, I think, and it’s what makes him compelling.
The win prevented the M’s from getting swept, but they need to start passing some of the teams in front or tied with them. There’s an awful lot of clutter in the wild card standings, and while the M’s aren’t out of it by any stretch, it’s always daunting seeing so many damn teams in the way. Some of them will have easier schedules. Some will just get hot randomly. And sure, some will fall by the wayside, and they should begin doing so. But it’s one thing to be behind the Jays and Angels, and another to have to deal with the Guardians and Rangers. Just clear the decks, and let the M’s have their straigh-uphill battle with top-shelf teams in the wild card race.
Today’s game is another great contrast. George Kirby, the young fireballer, makes his third MLB appearance. Opposing him is 42-year old Rich Hill, making appearance 331. Every move of Kirby’s has been scrutinized with pitch tracking. The M’s undoubtedly knew his spin rate before they drafted him. Contrast that with Hill, whose career predates PitchFX and pitch tracking. He just threw a cool curveball; he was into a mid-career renaissance before anyone knew how and why it worked (I guess because, for a few years there, it really didn’t).
Hill has always been primarily a fastball/curve guy, though he’ll mix in a slider and a rare change and cutter. He was up to about 55% FB/40% change in the pre-pandemic seasons, but now throws them equally, if you believe MLB’s statcast, and is fully 53% *curve* to 42% fastball by PitchInfo. His fastball was never overpowering, and now comes in at around 88mph, with solid carry/ride thanks to solid backspin. That helps it pair well with his big, slow curve, which is in the 68-72mph range with big two-plane break.
A lefty, Hill is used to facing overwhelmingly-right-handed line-ups. And he hasn’t really minded. In his long career, he’s yielded a .301 wOBA to righties, and .291 to lefties. His splits were noticeably higher last season, but nothing in the surrounding years (including 2022) shows that he’s lost his touch against righties. Still, it’s not a great AB for lefties, so no surprise the M’s have their righty-heavy line-up in. The fanbase is irate that Souza remains on the team, but if he does, this is when to play him. I’m not sure he should be, but he’s here, so he should probably play against Hill.
1: Frazier, LF
2: France, 1B
3: Rodriguez, CF
4: Winker, DH
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Torrens, C
7: Toro, 2B
8: Moore, SS
9: Souza, RF
SP: Kirby
Drew Steckenrider is back from the restricted list now that the M’s are out of Canada. Roenis Elias heads back to Tacoma. Ryan Divish reports Matt Festa is with the team, so it sounds like another move is coming.
Taylor Dollard won his first in AA (Despite already having a pitcher of the week win!) as Arkansas beat NW Arkansas 5-4. Everett beat Hillsboro 3-2, but Modesto fell to Stockton 9-7. Modesto did slug 5 HRs, with Edwin Arroyo getting his 7th, and Robert Perez blasting numbers 13 and 14.
Game 38, Mariners at Blue Jays
Marco Gonzales vs. Kevin Gausman, 4:05pm
Well. I thought that choosing between Steven Souza and Dylan Moore was a problem without a solution, and that Souza’s minute advantage vs. LHPs made it an understandable hold-your-nose-and-choose sort of a move. Then, the game absolutely turned on two plays in the 2nd inning. In the top, Souza grounded into a double play with the bases loaded, ending an early threat. In the bottom, he broke a bit late on a flare to right, dove, missed, turning it into a bases-clearing triple. Two bases loaded situations, both involving Souza, and the M’s lost 3-0 despite a brilliant game by Logan Gilbert. That’s the high quality of analysis you depend on here at USSM.
The other frustrating thing about the game is that it highlighted just why things aren’t going the M’s way. They were facing a pitcher with big platoon splits, and needed good lefties in the line-up. JP Crawford is a good lefty, but he’s also incredibly streaky – like, Raul Ibanez streaky. As hot as he was in April, he’s cooled off dramatically since. It’s fine; he’s a great player, and his season line would still be a career high. But you…notice that he’s in one of *those* zones right now, and thus the M’s aren’t able to really take advantage. What about Jesse Winker? Yeah, I think we all wanted a bit more from Winker, and it’s possible he’s going to be one of those guys whose value gets nuked by the deadened ball, but I also have to think he’ll get hot at some point. But the real vacancy, the real glaring hole last night was Jarred Kelenic. His demotion is what set the stage for the Sophie’s Choice Servais had to make. His struggles leave a team that just isn’t quite ready to play up to their potential.
Kelenic played for Tacoma today, and in a weird Monkey’s Paw sort of scene, was sandwiched by Kyle Lewis and Evan White in the batting order. The Rainiers were shut out in Sacramento, and the rehabbing trio went a combined 0-8. Kelenic had 3 Ks in his 0-4. Evan White went 6 innings, going 0-2 in that time; they’re still taking it easy with him, and this was his first game since his sports hernia surgery.
It’s easy to forget just how lost Robbie Ray looked before his move to Toronto in 2020. He was terrible in that Covid-shortened season, playing his way out of Arizona with an ERA near 8 and -0.5 fWAR. But the Jays unlocked something, and Ray won the Cy Young the next season. How would they replace him? Apparently, with another turnaround story. Ok, Kevin Gausman’s turnaround actually happened in San Francisco, but I was worried that whatever he learned wouldn’t stick, especially in a park that rewards elevated contact as richly as the Rogers Centre. One of the drawbacks Gausman had going back to his early years in Baltimore was HR issues, and even though he had solid control, he was more hittable than you’d want in an ace.
Well, that was wrong. Gausman’s splitter remains every bit the unhittable monster it became in SF, and while he’s still a bit hittable, he’s turned his good control into elite control, with a K:BB ratio this year of 54:2. Oh, and the HR thing? He doesn’t do that anymore. He’s pitched 45 IP thus far and still hasn’t yielded one. Nate Eovaldi gave up 5 in an *inning* yesterday to Houston, but Gausman, even in Toronto, is still at 0 for the year. Because his best pitch is that insane split, Gausman has run reverse splits for his career, and lefties have a sub-.200 wOBA against him this year. Let’s go Ty France! I love that France continues to rack up hits, but have to point out that he’s slugging .317 in May, so he’s going to need help. Let’s see if Julio can get Gausman off the dinger schneid today.
1: Frazier, RF (!)
2: France, 1B
3: Crawford, SS
4: Winker, LF
5: Suarez, 3B
6: Rodriguez, RF
7: Toro, 2B
8: Ford, DH
9: Raleigh, C
SP: Gonzales
As mentioned before, Tacoma lost 5-0 today. Darren McCaughan is off to a rough start, unfortunately. Matt Brash K’d 3 in 2 scoreless, without a walk I might add. They won the first game of the series last night 8-3, beating 6’11” pitching prospect Sean Hjelle in the process.
Arkansas beat NW Arkansas 7-6 as Cade Marlowe hit his second home run. Taylor Dollard starts for Arkansas tonight.
Everett and Hillsboro had an unfortunate Covid cancellation.
Modesto lost 4-3 to Stockton and rehabbing A’s starter Cole Irvin. Edwin Arroyo homered for the Nuts.